Most Idahoans do not spend their days reading House rules or following legislative procedure. They shouldn’t have to. But they understand this much: When people in power change the rules to keep criticism out of the public record, something is wrong.
That is exactly what happened in the Idaho House.
House Republicans used their supermajority to suspend rules and block a report from House Democrats from being entered into the legislative record. That report raised concerns about House Bill 822, including constitutional risks, dangers to vulnerable children and the rushed way the bill moved through the Legislature.
Lauren Necochea. File photo.
This legislation would require teachers, school counselors and health professionals to report to parents if a student identifies as transgender or asks to use a different name or pronouns. It also relies on broad language that could sweep in subjective judgments about appearance or dress. In practice, it forces adults in positions of trust to disclose personal information about a young person, even when doing so could put them at risk.
The report outlined issues Idahoans deserve to know about.
First, the bill imposes penalties of up to $100,000 — an extreme punishment that likely violates constitutional protections against excessive fines. By comparison, filing a false child abuse report carries statutory damages of $2,500. If the law is struck down, Idaho taxpayers could again pay the price for defending an unconstitutional statute in court.
Second, the bill relies on vague and subjective definitions that could leave teachers, counselors and medical professionals unsure what the law actually requires. Unclear laws create confusion, lawsuits and financial penalties for ordinary people trying to do their jobs.
Third, the bill contains no safety exception for situations where disclosure could put a child at risk of abuse, homelessness or violence. Professionals who work with children are trained to assess those risks carefully. This bill removes that judgment entirely.
This bill creates more problems than it solves. If a teenager confides in a school nurse but fears being thrown out of the house if their parents find out, that nurse faces an impossible choice: protect the child or risk crushing penalties. If a substitute teacher unknowingly uses a nickname a parent has not approved, should that really trigger lawsuits and six-figure fines?
Schools and health care providers are stretched thin. This bill would force them to create a reporting bureaucracy to monitor and police employee conduct, with the cost falling on taxpayers and patients.
This is bigger than one bill. It is about whether the people of Idaho get the full truth about what their government is doing in their name. Idaho deserves leaders confident enough to defend their ideas in the open and accountable enough to face scrutiny.
Lauren Necochea is chair of the Idaho Democratic Party and a former District 19 legislator. Necochea spent a decade leading nonprofit programs dedicated to research and advocacy in tax policy, health care and children’s issues.
Want to support independent local journalism?
The Sandpoint Reader is our town's local, independent weekly newspaper. "Independent" means that the Reader is locally owned and operated by people who were born and raised in Sandpoint. The Reader is owned by Publisher Ben Olson, Editor-in-Chief Zach Hagadone and Senior Writer Soncirey Mitchell. Sandpoint Reader LLC is a completely independent business unit; no big newspaper group or corporate conglomerate or billionaire owner dictates our editorial policy. And we want the news, opinion and lifestyle stories we report to be freely available to all interested readers - so unlike many other newspapers and media websites, we have NO PAYWALL on our website. The Reader relies wholly on the support of our valued advertisers, as well as readers who voluntarily contribute. Want to ensure that local, independent journalism survives in our town? You can help support the Reader for as little as $1.
TIMBER WARS: Six-part series, February-November 2022. GO READ IT»
WHERE ARE THE WORKERS?: Five-part series, September-October 2021. GO READ IT»
THE AMERICAN REDOUBT: Seven-part series, November-December 2017. GO READ IT»
STANDOFF AT RUBY RIDGE: 25 Years Later. Five-part series, August-September 2017. GO READ IT»
Curious about what media the locals use? Check our 2018 Local Media Survey. GO SEE »
Sandpoint in Pictures
Filmmaker Jimmy Matlosz of the Idaho Film Company has made a series of mini documentaries about influential Sandpoint locals, including the late Dann Hall and Erik Daarstad as well as icons Diane Michaels and Dan Shook. He is currently working on a series of interviews connected to the history of the Panida Theater. Jimmy is a 30-year veteran filmmaker who's work can be seen at dpmatlosz.com.
Meet the Reader
Ever wonder who makes the Reader happen? Here's a behind-the-scenes look pieced together by summer 2017 intern McCalee Cain in which Ben, Cameron and Lyndsie explain what exactly about the Reader keeps them coming back to their shabby (but well-loved) office each week.
